Burger reviews by city · Wilmington · Greater Wilmington field office

Best Burgers in Midtown Wilmington

Updated September 21, 2026 · changes with every inspection filed

20 burger spots on file in Midtown, 11 of them graded. Oklahoma's Original Burger leads with an A. Grades are the average of real inspections by badged inspectors — see how the Bureau grades. Opinions of burgers, not facts about restaurants.

The Ranking

11 graded spots · ranked by Bureau score

1. 1Oklahoma's Original BurgerA · 93.4Midtown · 2 inspections · Double Burger“one of few burgers i’ve had that didn’t get a soggy bun! patty could have been more flavorful and the onions were burnt but lettuce and t…”Class A
2. 2The Original Salt WorksA- · 90.0Midtown · 1 inspection · Double Cheeseburger“The bun was nice and soft. Lettuce and tomatoes were fresh. Tasted like a great diner burger. Also great price for double cheese burger w…”Class A
3. 3Carolina Ale HouseB+ · 88.7Midtown · 1 inspection · The Varsity Burger“The burger was very good and well priced. The toppings were fresh and the burger was seasoned and cooked to order. Our server was attenti…”
4. 4Mess HallB · 83.2Midtown · 3 inspections · McWhat?“The McWhat was an awesome burger. You could definitely taste the chicken and the burger separately in the sandwich. The toppings were cri…”
5. 5The SounderC+ · 79.2Midtown · 1 inspection · The Burger“Overall great burger , I will be back. I believe the burger lacked something … potentially more sauce, a few pickles would be nice . The…”
6. 6P.T.'s Olde Fashioned GrilleC+ · 78.0Midtown · 1 inspection · Olde Fashioned Burger“Burger was bigger than the bun. They didn’t ask how it should be cooked but it came slightly pink so medium to medium well. Jack cheese,…”
7. 7Kickback Jack's RestaurantC+ · 77.8Midtown · 3 inspections · Bacon Jam Burger“I ordered the burger, medium, and it was cooked perfectly. Large 8 ounce patty with fresh toppings and the bun held up to the very end. P…”
8. 8Molly Pitcher's American GrillC · 76.0Midtown · 2 inspections · Molly’s Chargrilled 1/2 lb Burger“Overall, this was a pretty good burger. The biggest downfall was, it was not cooked to order although it should’ve been it was very thick…”
9. 9Jimbo's Breakfast & LunchC- · 72.7Midtown · 1 inspection · Double Burger“You come here for the comfort and the service and mostly breakfast, and the food is usually excellent. My waitress was attentive and my c…”
10. 10Blue Surf CafeC- · 71.0Midtown · 2 inspections · Southern“Pimento cheese falls flat. Burger was salty. Heavy pre-pattied vibes.”
11. 11Moe's Original BBQC- · 70.3Midtown · 4 inspections · Rodeo Smokehouse Burger“Great smoked burger. Only available on Fridays.”